Elsevier

Science & Justice

Volume 55, Issue 6, December 2015, Pages 402-407
Science & Justice

Shifts in soil biodiversity—A forensic comparison between Sus scrofa domesticus and vegetation decomposition

https://doi.org/10.1016/j.scijus.2015.07.004Get rights and content

Highlights

  • Significant differences in 16S Shannon–Wiener and Simpson diversity recorded for the control vs. two burial soils

  • Distinct bacterial and fungal rRNA gene profile shifts for pig and grass soils, respectively

  • Temporal divergence in burial soils observed after Tukey (HSD)/Bonferroni post hoc tests

  • Potential applicability determined by sequencing and in situ studies

Abstract

In a forensic context, microbial-mediated cadaver decomposition and nutrient recycling cannot be overlooked. As a result, forensic ecogenomics research has intensified to gain a better understanding of cadaver/soil ecology interactions as a powerful potential tool for forensic practitioners. For this study, domestic pig (Sus scrofa domesticus) (4 g) and grass (Agrostis/Festuca spp) cuttings (4 g) were buried (July 2013 to July 2014) in sandy clay loam (80 g) triplicates in sealed microcosms (127 ml; 50 × 70 cm) with parallel soil only controls. The effects of the two carbon sources were determined by monitoring key environmental factors and changes in soil bacterial (16S rRNA gene) and fungal (18S rRNA gene) biodiversity. Soil pH changes showed statistically significant differences (p < 0.05) between the treatments. The measured ecological diversity indices (Shannon–Wiener, HꞋ; Simpson, D; and richness, S) of the 16S rRNA and 18S rRNA gene profiles also revealed differences between the treatments, with bacterial and fungal community dominance recorded in the presence of S. scrofa domesticus and grass trimming decomposition, respectively. In contrast, no statistically significant difference in evenness (p > 0.05) was observed between the treatments.

Introduction

Cadaver decomposition is a complex process that begins with post-mortem changes such as algor mortis, rigor mortis and livor mortis followed by soft tissue decomposition through the processes of autolysis, putrefaction, decay and skeletonization [1], [2], [3], [4], [5], [6]. The soft tissue decomposition stages are characterized by protein, carbohydrate and lipid catabolisms in the body [1], [2], [5]. The rate of cadaver decomposition can be influenced by both biotic and abiotic factors, which can vary between above- and underground situations [2], [3]. Studies which compared above- [7], [8], [9] and underground [10], [11], [12] scenarios have shown that cadaver decomposition rate is slower in the latter.

The application of fatty acid-based techniques, such as phospholipid fatty acid and fatty acid methyl ester analyses, and molecular techniques, such as polymerase chain reaction (PCR), denaturing/temperature gradient gel electrophoresis (T/DGGE) and terminal restriction length polymorphism (T-RFLP) with next generation sequencing for microbial community profiling, are beginning to elucidate the complex relationships between cadaver decomposition, nutrient cycling and soil microbial community dynamics in a forensic context [6], [13], [14], [15], [16], [17], [18]. For example, some sub-surface studies by Bergmann et al. [19] and Olakanye et al. [20] recorded spatial and temporal changes in soil bacterial diversity relative to burial depth and decomposition time, respectively. Also, aboveground studies by Lauber et al. [21] that investigated the roles of microorganisms in cadaver ecogenomics recorded changes in 16S rRNA bacterial, 16S rRNA archaeal, and 18S rRNA fungal communities in sterile and non-sterile soils with differences between skin-associated and grave soil during the active and advanced decay stages. Thus, several researchers have illustrated and suggested that changes in epinecrotic and burial soil microbial diversity can be a potential “post-mortem microbial clock” tool for PMI estimation [15], [16].

Although the possible use of forensic ecogenomics as a novel suite of techniques for crime scene investigation is gaining momentum [15], [16], [17], [19], [22], [23], more detailed studies are required to elucidate fully the interactions between soil ecology and cadaver decomposition (cadaver decomposition-mediated soil ecology changes). Consequently, the values of different microbial ecology tools in this novel context, including profiling platforms that are accessible to most researchers and practitioners, must be considered while taking full cognizance of their limitations. To explore this, two different carbon sources (S. scrofa domesticus and Agrostis/Festuca spp) were buried and studied over a one-year period (July 2013 to July 2014). The specific research questions were:

  • (i)

    What are the effects of abiotic factors such as temperature/pH on decompositional soil biodiversity?;

  • (ii)

    Will Sus scrofa domesticus and plant matter decompositions illicit the same trends or shifts in biodiversity compared to the soil only controls?;

  • (iii)

    Which biochemical and molecular markers (microbial community indices) can be employed reliably during S. scrofa domesticus decomposition? Thus, DGGE profiling was complemented by ecological community indices measurements of Shannon–Wiener and Simpson diversity, taxa richness and evenness.

Section snippets

Soil collection and characterization

Twenty kilograms of sandy clay loam soil was dug from a well secured site at Bishop Burton College of Agriculture, Lincolnshire, UK (Lat. 53.27°N, Long. 0.52°W) [24] and stored in a sterilized 25 l airtight bucket. To ensure homogeneity, the soil was milled thoroughly (Retsch SM 100, Retsch, Haan, Germany) and sieved (ASTM—standard soil sieve No 10; 2 mm mesh). The sandy clay loam soil was constituted (w/w) by 21% clay, 21% silt and 58% sand (Forestry Commission, Surrey, UK) and physicochemical

Temperature

Between days 0 and 60, the average microcosm temperature was 25.1 °C ± 0.31 while the atmosphere was 19.2 °C ± 0.19. The seasonal weather change then resulted in a temperature decrease that was marked from days 120 to 180 with an average of 8 °C ± 0.26. For days 300 to 365 temperature increases were apparent with an average of 14.5 °C ± 0.14. The two-way ANOVA showed a statistically significant difference (p < 0.001) between the atmospheric and microcosm temperatures but no difference (p > 0.05) between the S.

Discussion

Studies of cadaver decomposition and its interactions with, and effects on, soil ecology have highlighted the potential of forensic ecogenomics as a powerful tool to estimate PMI and identify clandestine graves through changes in microbial communities [14], [15], [16], [20], [21], [22], [23]. Although this tool has potential advantages compared with conventional methods for estimating PMI, most studies have, however, only considered a single carbon source (the cadaver) while dual sources can

Conclusion

Abiotic factors such as temperature and pH are key variables in taphonomic studies. This research identified interesting trends, as revealed by an accessible ecogenomics technique and multiple and robust statistical analyses, that could be useful in identifying a cadaver grave by targeting specific microbial community diversity changes. In this study microcosms were used but an extensive whole carcass program is in progress and should result in more comprehensive data by targeting specific

Acknowledgments

The authors thank Lorraine White for granting site access for soil collection.

References (39)

Cited by (14)

  • The cyclic nature of soil chemistry: Forensic analysis with the aid of ultra-high performance liquid chromatography

    2022, Talanta Open
    Citation Excerpt :

    Many studies of forensic soil analysis focus on adapting existing methods from other disciplines, and often many different techniques and analyses are required to match or exclude reference samples from evidentiary samples [11, 12]. These techniques can range from rapid, inexpensive, and requiring minimal training such as visual analysis and pH measurement, to quite complex processes [13, 14]. This creates a costly, confusing, and time-consuming process, thereby reinforcing the perception of this area of forensics as not very user-friendly.

  • Soil metabarcoding identifies season indicators and differentiators of pig and Agrostis/Festuca spp. decomposition

    2018, Forensic Science International
    Citation Excerpt :

    1.2349°W). As reported previously [14], triplicate microcosms (polyethylene, 127 ml, 50 × 70 mm; VWR, Lutterworth, U.K.) were established for each of the control (80 g soil), S. scrofa domesticus (soil + 4 g pig) and Agrostis/Festuca spp. (soil + 4 g plant litter) to enable destructive sampling on days 7, 14, 28, 60, 120, 180, 300 and 365 between July 2013 and July 2014. These microcosms were perforated every 7 mm (width) × 35 mm (height) for hygiene maintenance, aeration and moisture migration.

  • Summary: An assessment of achievements, limitations, and potential of forensic ecogenomics

    2018, Forensic Ecogenomics: The Application of Microbial Ecology Analyses in Forensic Contexts
  • The role of the microbiome in PMI estimation

    2018, Forensic Ecogenomics: The Application of Microbial Ecology Analyses in Forensic Contexts
  • General introduction: Method applications at the interface of microbial ecology and forensic investigation

    2018, Forensic Ecogenomics: The Application of Microbial Ecology Analyses in Forensic Contexts
  • The method debate: A state-of-the-art analysis of PMI estimation techniques

    2018, Forensic Ecogenomics: The Application of Microbial Ecology Analyses in Forensic Contexts
View all citing articles on Scopus
View full text